Cat 01
Licensing & Compliance
1 of 1 source checks verifiedSignal
SAM.gov federal exclusions
Result
No exclusions found
Checked August 2026
SAM.gov
Verified
McCarthy Metal Roofing - Roofing Contractor in Raleigh, NC
Timothy P. McCarthy, Owner · Established 1986
40+
Years in Business
25
Reviews
Accreditation Status
Cycle 2026
Status
Not Accredited
Review not yet completed
McCarthy Metal Roofing has not yet been reviewed for ARCO Accreditation.
ARCO Accreditation is reserved for roofing businesses that complete a comprehensive review and meet ARCO's required qualification threshold. Not every business reviewed qualifies.
Issued only after successful review
Accreditation No.
Not Issued
Accreditation Status
Not Accredited
Accreditation Review
Not Completed
Qualification Status
Not Determined
About ARCO Accreditation
Accreditation cannot be obtained through application alone. Each business must first undergo ARCO's complete review process and demonstrate that it meets the standards required for accreditation.
Inquire About an Accreditation Review
Provide your contact information below. ARCO will review your inquiry and determine whether your business may be invited to complete the accreditation review process.
Public Record
What we can independently confirm today
Findings drawn from public records, manufacturer registries, and third-party review platforms — synthesized using ARCO Standard 2026.1.
Public Signals Reviewed
14
across 4 categories
Customer Review Rating
4.6/5.0
across 25 verified reviews
Years in Business
40+yrs
Founded 1986
Accreditation Review
Not Yet Completed
Qualification has not been determined
Accreditation Committee Review
No committee determination has been issued.
Not Yet ConductedThe source findings below have been independently verified for this company profile. A formal ARCO Accreditation Committee review has not yet been completed, and qualification for accreditation has not been determined.
Only businesses that complete the full review and meet ARCO's required threshold may receive accreditation.
Cat 02
Operational History & Stability
5 of 5 source checks verifiedSignal
Years in operation
Result
40+ years continuous
Founded: 1986
Verified record
Verified
Signal
Owner/principal
Result
Mr. Timothy P. McCarthy
Manual collection
Verified
Signal
Service mix
Result
Metal Roofing, Flat Roofing, Church Metal Roofing, Do-it-yourself, and Extreme Weather Roofing
Service area: North Carolina
Website profile
Verified
Signal
Website registration
Result
Registered: Dec 3, 2013
WHOIS/RDAP
Verified
Signal
Google Business Profile
Result
McCarthy Metal Roofing
Raleigh, NC
Verified
Cat 04
Customer Outcome Data
3 of 4 source checks verifiedSignal
Aggregated marketplace rating
Result
4.6 / 5.0 across 25 reviews
Google 4.6 (25)
Multi-source
Verified
Signal
Review volume
Result
25 stored public reviews
Multi-source
Source available
Signal
Customer review excerpts
Result
6 qualifying reviews on file
Multi-source reviews
Verified
Signal
BBB rating
Result
A+ / BBB Accredited
BBB Accredited since: May 26, 2011
BBB profile
Verified
Cat 05
Complaint & Public Findings
2 of 2 source checks verifiedSignal
OSHA findings
Result
No violations across 0 inspections
OSHA
Verified
Signal
BBB complaint history
Result
No complaints filed in the last 36 months
Years in business: 40 - Business started: Dec 1, 1985
BBB profile
Verified
Public records and third-party platform data may change over time. ARCO does not guarantee ongoing third-party accuracy.
Report no.
NC-260808-953
·
Evaluated Aug 8, 2026
·
Independently verifiable at
RoofingContractors.org/verify/NC-260808-953
Eligibility · All Cleared
Automatic eligibility checks cleared
ARCO automatically withholds accreditation when any of the following findings are present. McCarthy Metal Roofing's record was checked against each.
Active SAM.gov federal exclusion
None Found
Checked August 2026 · No exclusions on record
OSHA willful violation or 3+ repeat violations on record
None Found
0 inspections · clean OSHA establishment record
BBB rating of C, D, or F
None Found
Rated A+ · BBB-accredited since May 26, 2011
Avg. customer rating < 4.0 (with ≥ 20 reviews)
None Found
4.6/5.0 · 25 verified reviews
About McCarthy Metal Roofing
McCarthy Metal Roofing is a Raleigh, North Carolina-based company owned by Mr. Timothy P. McCarthy that specializes in a comprehensive range of commercial and residential roofing solutions. The business offers professional expertise in roof inspections and repairs, covering everything from routine maintenance and leak fixes to storm damage restoration and consulting.
Services & Specialties
What McCarthy Metal Roofing does.
01
Storm Damage
02
Metal Roofing
03
Flat / Low-Slope Roofing
04
Institutional Roofing
Based in Raleigh
Contact McCarthy Metal Roofing to confirm availability for your project in North Carolina.
Nearby places
Raleigh, NC
Garner, NC
Fuquay-Varina, NC
Holly Springs, NC
Angier, NC
Cary, NC
Clayton, NC
Contact McCarthy Metal Roofing to confirm service at your address.
Aggregated review summary
25
reviews analyzed
Google
25 reviews
ARCO Review Findings
McCarthy Metal Roofing is consistently praised for its professional, knowledgeable staff and high-quality workmanship. Clients frequently highlight the company's seamless, hassle-free process, noting that crews are punctual, thorough with site cleanup, and highly responsive to questions and concerns.
5 recent reviews
B
Bob Q.
Google
I had my 1800+ square foot mobile home roof replaced with a metal roof. I have dealt with a number of contractors over the years and could not have been happier with the professionalism of Tim and his people. From the estimate to the clean-up, it was a joy! And they are still checking in with me over two years later to make sure I am happy with my "new" roof. One of the best companies I have ever dealt with.
A
Ashley H.
Google
We are very pleased with our Classic Metal Roof purchase from McCarthy Metal Roofing. We were looking for a permanent, aesthetically pleasing alternative to typical shingles and found it with our metal roof. Through the entire process everyone was professional and informative. Our roof looks great and we feel so relieved to know it is taken care of for good! The crew working on the roof was always on time and cleaned up after themselves each day. They even made friends with our outside pets. Any concerns or questions we had were addressed quickly and handled to our satisfaction. We are very pleased we found such a great company and product for our home
C
Crystal K.
Google
McCarthy Metal Roofing is the best company I have ever worked with during all of my renovations and other projects. Everyone at the company is professional and courteous with an exceptionally high level of knowledge about their products and services. I will never use any other roofing company. McCarthy Metal Roofing has earned my trust and loyalty. I only wish all companies could be like McCarthy Metal Roofing. They raise the standard for quality and service. Thank you for my beautiful, energy efficient, long lasting roof! You are the best!
M
Maria J.
Google
McCarthy Metal Roofing did a great job with my new roof, the process was easy and all my questions were answered, the crew left my house clean and the roof looks really nice, I'm impressed with Dave and Dale professionalism. My neighbors all stopped to compliment the new roof! overall a good experience, I'm busy with work and this was the most hassle free experience I've ever had with contractors
L
Lucas J.
Google
I am not a customer of McCarthy Metal Roofing but rather a business consultant that has been working with the company for over a year. Based on my 30 years of experience in improving businesses, I can say the company has some of the better systems in place to ensure quality and customer satisfaction. I would recommend purchasing a roof from them without any reservation.
Review data aggregated from public sources · ARCO does not moderate third-party reviews
Why Hire an ARCO-Accredited Roofer
The difference between "good enough" and proven excellence. Only the top roofers in America earn ARCO Accreditation — recognition of true craftsmanship, ethics, and integrity.
Homeowner Benefits
-
Peace of Mind: Every ARCO-Accredited roofer has been checked against public licensing records, safety records, complaint history, and verified customer reviews.
-
Work You Can Trust: ARCO's evaluation includes manufacturer certification programs — credentials that can help preserve your roof's warranty coverage.
-
Verified, Not Self-Reported: ARCO's findings come from government and third-party sources — state filing offices, SAM.gov, OSHA, and the BBB — not from paperwork a contractor submits about itself.
-
A Public Paper Trail: Every accredited profile publishes its report number, evaluation date, and sources — so any homeowner can independently verify the findings at RoofingContractors.org.
What Accreditation Means
- License & Registration Verification
- State Filing & Standing Review
- Federal Exclusion Screening
- OSHA Safety Record Review
- Complaint History Screening
- Customer Review Evaluation
- Annual Re-certification
Contact McCarthy Metal Roofing
Ready to request an estimate?
Call (919) 900-1100 or request a written estimate through www.northcarolinametalroofs.com.