In October 2026, a homeowner named Joseph K. sat down and wrote a short review with one name in the first line. "Brent Collier and Staff made the entire process an actual pleasure," Joseph wrote. "The Quality of work and efficiency was exceptional."

The Brent in question started out as a college kid on a summer roofing crew.

A summer job that stuck

Buckeye State Roofing was founded in 2010 by Brent Collier, who, the company says, "developed a passion for roofing while working during the summers throughout college." A graduate of The Ohio State University, he used what he had learned in the classroom and on the roof to start a business of his own in Hinckley. ARCO's 2026 evaluation found an active Ohio Secretary of State filing for the company, formed in May 2010.

His reason for starting it is printed on the company's website, in his own words. "When I started Buckeye State Roofing, it was out of a deep love and respect for my community," Brent says. "I chose to work in this industry because I knew I could offer a higher quality of roofing. Our craftsmanship is second to none, we are honest, and we care about our customers."

More than a decade and a half later, he adds, "We started in this industry in 2010 and have been family owned and operated ever since."

Walked through, never pushed

Customers describe a company that explains things. Matt P. wrote in October 2026 that "Brent was so helpful throughout the process, taking the time to walk me through everything and making sure I felt comfortable every step of the way."

Mark M. wrote in September 2026 that Buckeye State gave a complete tear-off and replacement for a house and an outbuilding. "I never felt any pressure after asking for their estimate," Mark wrote. Deborah K. had a storm-damage inspection in August 2026 and called the visit "fair, honest, and very pleasant regarding the needed repair work with no pressure to immediately require getting a new roof."

The company says it was founded on honest estimates and reliable communication, and that free inspections and estimates are part of the offer. Homeowners can usually expect a visit within a couple of days, according to its FAQ.

Done in a day, left clean

Speed and cleanup come up again and again. Darlene B. wrote in September 2026, "We had a tear off and new roof done. We are very happy with the new results, which was done in one day."

Dave W. had a roof replaced and wrote in August 2026 that the crew "did an excellent job from start to finish." The reviewer added, "You could hardly tell they had been there except for the beautiful new roof!"

Homes, businesses and a credit union

The company handles residential, commercial and metal roofing, siding, windows, storm damage repair and ice dam removal. It serves homeowners across Northeast Ohio, including Medina, Brunswick, Strongsville, Parma, North Royalton, North Olmsted, Parma Heights, Brook Park, North Ridgeville and Wadsworth.

In Wadsworth, Jeff C. wrote in September 2026 that Medina County Federal Credit Union had Buckeye State "replace our roof, skylights, and gutters." Jeff's verdict: "From start to finish, the entire team was professional, dependable, and very easy to work with."

Backed by the manufacturer

Buckeye State Roofing is a GAF Master Elite contractor, a certification the company says only about 2 percent of roofing companies in the country earn. It says every roof replacement carries a 10-year standard workmanship warranty, with 25 years of workmanship coverage available through GAF's Golden Pledge.

ARCO's 2026 evaluation, which scores contractors from public records under the ARCO Standard 2026.1, also confirmed Owens Corning Preferred status, an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2016), a clean OSHA record and a 4.9-star average across 291 public reviews. It gave Buckeye State Roofing a composite score of 9.6 out of 10.

Ohioans, through and through

"We're Ohioans, through and through!" the company writes. "We love the state that's helped made us who we are, and the people who have made us even better."

For Brent Collier, that has meant staying put in Hinckley, keeping the business in the family and keeping the focus on the neighbors who call. Homeowners can read the independent findings on the company's ARCO profile or visit buckeyestateroofing.com.

This feature was produced by the ARCO Editorial Team from public sources, including the company's website (its home, about, residential roofing and FAQ pages), ARCO's 2026 evaluation (including its Ohio Secretary of State, Better Business Bureau and OSHA checks) and published Google customer reviews from 2026. Customer reviews and company statements are quoted as written, with light punctuation edits.


ARCO Accreditation Status

Buckeye State Roofing qualified for ARCO accreditation in the Class of 2026 as a 2026 Top Rated Roofing Contractor in Ohio.

Own or work at Buckeye State Roofing? Activate your accreditation →