Cat 01
Licensing & Compliance
1 of 1 source checks verifiedSignal
SAM.gov federal exclusions
Result
No exclusions found
Checked August 2026
SAM.gov
Verified
Watertight Roofing Indy - Roofing Contractor in Indianapolis, IN
Richard Hathaway Jr., Owner · Established 1939
87+
Years in Business
6
Reviews
Accreditation Status
Cycle 2026
Status
Not Accredited
Review not yet completed
Watertight Roofing Indy has not yet been reviewed for ARCO Accreditation.
ARCO Accreditation is reserved for roofing businesses that complete a comprehensive review and meet ARCO's required qualification threshold. Not every business reviewed qualifies.
Issued only after successful review
Accreditation No.
Not Issued
Accreditation Status
Not Accredited
Accreditation Review
Not Completed
Qualification Status
Not Determined
About ARCO Accreditation
Accreditation cannot be obtained through application alone. Each business must first undergo ARCO's complete review process and demonstrate that it meets the standards required for accreditation.
Inquire About an Accreditation Review
Provide your contact information below. ARCO will review your inquiry and determine whether your business may be invited to complete the accreditation review process.
Public Record
What we can independently confirm today
Findings drawn from public records, manufacturer registries, and third-party review platforms — synthesized using ARCO Standard 2026.1.
Public Signals Reviewed
13
across 4 categories
Customer Review Rating
5.0/5.0
across 6 verified reviews
Years in Business
87+yrs
Founded 1939
Accreditation Review
Not Yet Completed
Qualification has not been determined
Accreditation Committee Review
No committee determination has been issued.
Not Yet ConductedThe source findings below have been independently verified for this company profile. A formal ARCO Accreditation Committee review has not yet been completed, and qualification for accreditation has not been determined.
Only businesses that complete the full review and meet ARCO's required threshold may receive accreditation.
Cat 02
Operational History & Stability
2 of 3 source checks verifiedSignal
Years in operation
Result
87+ years continuous
Founded: Apr 1, 1939
Verified record
Verified
Signal
Owner/principal
Result
Richard Hathaway Jr.
Manual collection
Verified
Signal
Website registration
Result
Website present, registration date missing
WHOIS/RDAP
Source available
Cat 04
Customer Outcome Data
3 of 4 source checks verifiedSignal
Aggregated marketplace rating
Result
5.0 / 5.0 across 6 reviews
BBB · 6 reviews on file
Multi-source
Verified
Signal
Review volume
Result
6 stored public reviews
Multi-source
Source available
Signal
Customer review excerpts
Result
5 qualifying reviews on file
Multi-source reviews
Verified
Signal
BBB rating
Result
A+ / BBB Accredited
BBB Accredited since: May 26, 2006
BBB profile
Verified
Cat 05
Complaint & Public Findings
2 of 2 source checks verifiedSignal
OSHA findings
Result
No violations across 0 inspections
OSHA
Verified
Signal
BBB complaint history
Result
No complaints filed in the last 36 months
Years in business: 87 - Business started: Apr 1, 1939
BBB profile
Verified
Public records and third-party platform data may change over time. ARCO does not guarantee ongoing third-party accuracy.
Report no.
IN-261016-8163
·
Evaluated Oct 16, 2026
·
Independently verifiable at
RoofingContractors.org/verify/IN-261016-8163
Eligibility · All Cleared
Automatic eligibility checks cleared
ARCO automatically withholds accreditation when any of the following findings are present. Watertight Roofing Indy's record was checked against each.
Active SAM.gov federal exclusion
None Found
Checked August 2026 · No exclusions on record
OSHA willful violation or 3+ repeat violations on record
None Found
0 inspections · clean OSHA establishment record
BBB rating of C, D, or F
None Found
Rated A+ · BBB-accredited since May 26, 2006
Avg. customer rating < 4.0 (with ≥ 20 reviews)
None Found
6 reviews (threshold: 20)
About Watertight Roofing Indy
Watertight Roofing Indy is listed in the ARCO contractor directory for Indianapolis, IN. Additional profile details are being compiled from the business and public records.
Based in Indianapolis
Contact Watertight Roofing Indy to confirm availability for your project in Indiana.
Nearby places
Indianapolis, IN
Plainfield, IN
Avon, IN
Speedway, IN
Brownsburg, IN
Mooresville, IN
Danville, IN
Contact Watertight Roofing Indy to confirm service at your address.
Aggregated review summary
6
reviews analyzed
BBB
6 reviews
5 recent reviews
L
Linda B.
BBB · Jul 2025
I called Watertight Roofing because I had several shingles that had blown off of my roof. [redacted] came to my house within hours of my calling him. He not only replaced the missing shingles but also re-secured my utility pole which was loosening. I felt he was very honest, knowledgeable and was reasonable in his pricing. I would definitely contact him again with any future roofing needs.
R
Randy L.
BBB · Apr 2025
[redacted] with Watertight Roofing did a good job of coordinating a schedule around always changing spring weather. Quality of the work was spot on and work was completed on time and on budget. [redacted] was very polite and courteous. Trusted and reliable contractor based upon my experience
A
Anthony R.
BBB · Mar 2025
A+ service! Amazing attention to detail. Very responsive, and will absolutely use again!
L
Linda H.
BBB · Mar 2025
Watertight Roofing did a very good job of repairing my vinyl siding. They were professional and got the work done promptly. I would definitely call them again if I have another problem with my siding or roof.
C
Catherine S.
BBB · Feb 2025
[redacted] was excellent! He gave me an honest opinion about my roof and quickly took care of an issue with sagging soffits. Very friendly and professional. Will definitely recommend to others!
Review data aggregated from public sources · ARCO does not moderate third-party reviews
Why Hire an ARCO-Accredited Roofer
The difference between "good enough" and proven excellence. Only the top roofers in America earn ARCO Accreditation — recognition of true craftsmanship, ethics, and integrity.
Homeowner Benefits
-
Peace of Mind: Every ARCO-Accredited roofer has been checked against public licensing records, safety records, complaint history, and verified customer reviews.
-
Work You Can Trust: ARCO's evaluation includes manufacturer certification programs — credentials that can help preserve your roof's warranty coverage.
-
Verified, Not Self-Reported: ARCO's findings come from government and third-party sources — state filing offices, SAM.gov, OSHA, and the BBB — not from paperwork a contractor submits about itself.
-
A Public Paper Trail: Every accredited profile publishes its report number, evaluation date, and sources — so any homeowner can independently verify the findings at RoofingContractors.org.
What Accreditation Means
- License & Registration Verification
- State Filing & Standing Review
- Federal Exclusion Screening
- OSHA Safety Record Review
- Complaint History Screening
- Customer Review Evaluation
- Annual Re-certification
Contact Watertight Roofing Indy
Ready to request an estimate?
Call (317) 248-3704 or request a written estimate through watertightroofingindy.com.